Seagull - I follow the game closely enough to know that is not true. I could give you all kinds of examples - in fact one just happened with Aroldis Chapman staying with the Yankees. He could have gotten more out on the market.
When Strasburg signed his last extension ($25 million per year) with the Nats he left money on the table. Goldschmidt signed with St Louis 5 years for $130 million and that's just a couple.
Heck, Mike Trout himself signed an extension worth $36 million per year. For 10 years. If he had played that situation differently he could have gotten so much more over those years.
That annual value will be swamped easily just this offseason! And Trout is the best player in the game but he likes it where he is and is already well paid. But not top dollar paid.
https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/extensiontracker
Sure, some guys go for bottom dollar. But some guys do not. Some agents do, some do not. It all depends on the situation. Some guys want rings and will sign for less (see JD Martinez) to chase one. Then when they get one, priorities might change.
So it all depends. As for Puig, it's a position problem for me. He plays RF, and quite well. And it's Franmil's only position right now. So I don't see it.
"I've suffered a great many tragedies in my life....most of them never happened". Mark Twain