21728
by Hillbilly
Well, unfortunately, the reason Naquin ended up back in AAA last year following his very good rookie campaign was because his defense in CF is sub par. That is why Zimmer is with the team despite his bat being sub par so far, too.
Both Brantley and Chisenhall are free agents at seasons end. I doubt either will be back. Brantley will probably demand too much money, assuming he stays healthy all year this year and puts up his normal numbers. And Chisenhall just has not been able to stay healthy either. Hard for a team like Cleveland to invest a lot of money in either of those two with their injury history.
I have thought for some time now our future OF will be Naquin in LF, Allen in CF, and Zimmer in RF. ... Mostly due to Zimmer having a better arm than Allen, and also to save Zimmer from himself. He stays in CF he's eventually going to kill himself running through walls with his kamikazi style. But if Zimmer's bat doesn't come along with experience, and I must say I have been underwhelmed so far this year, he may find himself on the bubble. Not sure he will be the bat we want in RF.
You guys can call me kooky but if you give me the choice of the two prospects long term in CF, I will take Allen any day of the week. I'd choose Allen over Naquin too. I've been a huge supporter of Allen since his first year in our system. He will be a prototypical CF'er and lead off hitter. Kind of guy that isn't easy to find. Poor mans Lofton.