Let’s take an early spring training trip around the Guardians’ diamond: The week in baseball
Updated: Mar. 01, 2025, 10:12 a.m.|Published: Mar. 01, 2025, 5:15 a.m.
By Paul Hoynes, cleveland.com
CLEVELAND, Ohio — February is over. The Cactus League season is rolling into March and the season opener in Kansas City is less than a month away.
It’s time for a trip around the diamond to get an early look at how things are going for the Guardians.
First base
Carlos Santana is excited to be back in Cleveland. He’ll play this season at 39, but he looks great. He has his own chef and he’s eating right.
Santana didn’t have a hit through the first six Cactus League games, but he’s played well defensively

. Kyle Manzardo has seen time at first and DH and is swinging the bat well. He has a chance for some serious playing time as Cleveland looks for offense to replace departed Josh Naylor.
Second base
The search for Andres Gimenez’s replacement continues. Through the first six spring games, the Guards have started four different second basemen. Gabriel Arias and Juan Brito have each started twice. Angel Martinez and Tyler Freeman have started the other two games.
Freeman and Arias have swung the bat well. Arias is out of options. Brito, coming off a great season at Triple-A Columbus, hasn’t made much contact

.
Arias has made only eight starts in the big leagues and 21 in the minors at second base. Brito, who has yet to play in the big leagues, has made 275 starts at second in the minors. Martinez has made one start at second in the big leagues and 185 in the minors. Freeman has made 20 starts at second base in the big leagues and 92 in the minors.
Daniel Schneemann, who did not start at second through the first six Cactus League games, has made three starts at second in the big leagues and 83 in the minors.
The next three weeks will reveal if there’s an everyday second baseman in that group.
Third base
All-Star Jose Ramirez looks like he’s dropped a few pounds. Just like he did last year when he had one of his best seasons.
Ramirez resides in the far corner of the spring training locker room next to Santana, Gavin Williams, Triston McKenzie and Shane Bieber. It seems like there’s always a party going on there.
When Ramirez needs a break at the hot corner, Schneemann or Arias usually spelled him last year.
Shortstop
Last year Brayan Rocchio hit .333 (11 for 33) in the postseason against the Tigers and Yankees after hitting .206 in the regular season. This spring the switch-hitter has been hitting like the postseason never ended. On defense, he’s played well despite losing his double-play partner Gimenez.
Arias, Schneemann and Freeman filled in for Rocchio at short last year.
Catcher
Bo Naylor spent the winter at the team’s training facility in Goodyear trying to find his swing. He hit just .201 (71 for 354) with 13 homers and 39 RBI last season. The results have been mixed this spring

.
Austin Hedges is behind Naylor. He hit just .152 (20 for 132) last year. David Fry won’t be around to provide some offense at the position because he’s opening the year on the injured list.
The one thing spring training has revealed is that the Guardians may have a catcher who can actually hit in prospect Cooper Ingle. He went 3 for 4 in his first three Cactus League games.
Ingle is in camp as a spring training invitee.
Designated hitter
Twelve players made starts at DH last year. Not sure if it will be that crowded this year with Manzardo and Santana. Still, manager Stephen Vogt likes to use the DH spot to give players a break during the season. Ramirez made 32 starts at DH last year, while Fry made 40.
Left field
In his first two Cactus League at-bats this spring, Steven Kwan dumped a single into left field and homered over the wall in center field at Goodyear Ballpark. Is anyone surprised with that?
Kwan had a season of extremes last year.
He went into the All-Star break hitting an MLB-leading .352 (99 for 281). After the break, he hit .206 (41 for 199) 
. He bounced back in the postseason, hitting .381 (16 for 42).
If Kwan can find a happy medium, and stay off the injured list, look out.
Center field
The prospect of a full season from a healthy Lane Thomas is looking better and better. The Guardians acquired Thomas from Washington at the trade deadline last year. He almost immediately went into a prolonged slump before hitting seven homers and driving in 20 runs in September. In the postseason, he hit .316 (6 for 19) with two homers and nine RBI against the Tigers in the ALDS.
Thomas homered in his first Cactus League at-bat.
Right field
The platoon of Will Brennan and Jhonkensy Noel is still in place. Brennan came to camp stronger after a winter in the weight room. Noel spent a lot of time in Goodyear this winter, trying to refine his swing. Prospect Chase DeLauter did not play in the first six Cactus League games. The Guardians are slow playing him to take every precaution that he can get through a season healthy.
Starting rotation
There’s been some good starts and some bad ones through the first six games. Gavin Williams and Joey Cantillo have looked sharp. Newcomer Luis Ortiz and Triston McKenzie struggled.
No. 1 starter Tanner Bibee has yet to pitch in a Cactus League game. 
Vogt and his coaching staff are going to need all of spring training to sort through this.
[
Guardians Star Pitcher Unveils Shocking Injury Revelation
This Cleveland Guardians pitcher has dropped some very surprising injury news.
Matthew Schmidt | Feb 28, 2025
......But want to hear something wild? Bibee was apparently pitching through an injury the entire time, as Eric Samulski of NBC Sports has revealed that the right-hander was dealing with a shoulder issue.......
......"Tanner Bibee told me that his shoulder was 'a little banged up most of last year,'" Samulski posted on X. "Has worked on mechanical tweaks to get his arm through cleaner without pain. Wouldn’t have known he was battling that from his results in 2024."...... ]
Bullpen
We haven’t seen the Guardians' pride and joy in its full glory yet. Emmanuel Clase, Hunter Gaddis, Tim Herrin and Cade Smith, who all made more than 80 appearances last year, have been eased into the Cactus League schedule. A lot of relief innings have gone to depth camp pitchers and those competing for a rotation spot. Two of them, Kolby Allard and Doug Nikhazy, have looked sharp.
Veteran right-hander Paul Sewald, signed to give the core of the bullpen a break, made his first appearance on Thursday. He allowed a run on two hits in two-thirds of an inning against the White Sox.
<