A Joez Favorite
You could just substitute Acta's name for Valentine and the article would ring true.
Dead manager walking
BRIAN MacPHERSON Providence Journal
Journal Sports Writer
bmacpherson@providencejournal.com
Published: 02 September 2012 09:03 PM
OAKLAND, Calif. — Bobby Valentine has a contract for this season and next. Valentine still is showing up for work every day, albeit not always at the time one would expect.
Valentine just doesn’t seem to want his job much anymore.
Asked how difficult the six-game losing streak has been on Sunday evening, a despondent Valentine just muttered, “What difference does it make?”
As disappointment has given way to embarrassment in what’s trending toward the worst season the Red Sox have experienced in almost a half-century, the manager looks more and more like he’s ready to get out and move on, to accept the pink slip he’ll undoubtedly receive once the season ends — if not sooner.
Not much could sum it up better than the scene of Valentine standing on the periphery of the Alfredo Aceves-Dustin Pedroia argument in the dugout on Saturday night, chomping on gum, hands in his pockets, watching while pitching coach Randy Niemann and third-base coach Jerry Royster took charge. Once Aceves and Pedroia had been separated, Valentine made a comment or two, but both Aceves and Pedroia seemed to dismiss whatever Valentine was trying to tell them — and Aceves even jawed back until Royster once again stepped in.
What has happened to the Red Sox can’t all be pinned on Valentine. Most of it has little to do with the manager. The collective 5.08 ERA the starting pitchers have compiled, for example, has little to do with the manager. Nor do the more than two dozen players — including Jacoby Ellsbury, David Ortiz and Dustin Pedroia — who have spent time on the disabled list.
It’s tough to argue, however, that Valentine has done much to put the Red Sox in a better position to win. Indeed, it seems as though he’s antagonized just about everyone at some point or another this season — and that any authority he might have had has completely evaporated.
Communication with half his coaching staff has been non-existent. Communication with most of the players in his clubhouse has been close to non-existent, too. When Jose Iglesias and Ryan Lavarnway were called up, there was no indication Valentine had spoken either to Mike Aviles or Jarrod Saltalamacchia about how their respective roles might change.
(It then took Valentine four days to get Iglesias on the field after his call-up — after which he said, “There’s really no reason to have Iglesias here if he doesn’t get some action.”)
Aceves was never told outright he no longer was the closer. Valentine instead began hinting in cryptic fashion he might have the former closer stretched out to start. When asked if the impetus for that plan had been a request from Aceves himself, Valentine offered an answer that was completely indecipherable.
“Boy, there’s been a lot of conversations,” he said. “I’m not sure that one’s been had in my office. It might have taken place and hasn’t filtered back to me yet, or it might have been presented and not been presented as something he has requested personally.”
Decision after decision is perplexing.
Once Iglesias started playing, it seemed to make sense to move Aviles over to third base once in a while to keep him in the lineup. Valentine declined to do so. He instead played Mauro Gomez — a first baseman by trade who’s woefully out of his element at third — at third base on Sunday.
Eyebrows were raised Friday afternoon when Valentine walked into the visitors’ clubhouse at O.co Coliseum at 4:19 p.m., less than three hours before the first pitch. He’d had to pick up his son at the airport, he said.
Eyebrows were raised again Saturday night when Valentine wrote Scott Podsednik into the No. 3 hole in his lineup. Podsednik is a perfectly serviceable major-league player in the right role, but the fact that he’s barely hit more career home runs (42) than triples (41) is an indication he’s not a No. 3 hitter.
The reaction from Valentine when asked about the decision made as little sense as the decision itself.
“Just a mistake,” he deadpanned in such a way that it was hard to tell if he was joking. “Is that what it says on the lineup? What the (expletive). Switch it up. Who knows? Maybe it will look good. I haven’t seen it.”
Eyebrows now have to be raised every time Aceves gets up in the Boston bullpen. He didn’t pitch Sunday, but he threw an astounding 143 pitches in the five games the Red Sox played before that. That’s an incredible workload for any pitcher, but it’s especially incredible for a pitcher who already seemed to be showing signs of wearing down after having pitched almost 200 innings in well over 100 appearances in the last two seasons.
Maybe Valentine is just trying to win games any way he can to try to get his team back into contention.
More likely, however, is that Valentine is trying to do what so many football coaches do every Saturday and Sunday: He’s punting down 14 points in the fourth quarter. In other words, he’s trying to keep the score close — not in games, in this case, but in the team’s record.
By playing Podsednik and Cody Ross in every game rather than Ryan Kalish, for example, he might be trying to avoid the catastrophic end toward which Boston appears to be hurtling, trying to avoid the embarrassment of being the first Red Sox manager to lose 90 games since 1965.
But there’s no difference between losing 85 games or 90 games, and if a player like Kalish is going to be a building block on the roster, this is the time to find out.
Instead, even as the losses keep piling up, Valentine just keeps making empty statements about winning with no substance behind them.
When asked about his expectations for September, he said, “I think we’re going to win a lot of games this last month.”
Given the way things have gone, a follow-up question was obligatory: Why do you think that?
“Why shouldn’t I think that?” he shot back. “Because I’m the manager of the team and we get paid to play and win, and I believe that we’re going to win.”
That’s a ringing endorsement.
Why do I think we’re going to win? Because I’m contractually obligated to think we’re going to win! Go get ‘em, fellas!”
It’s about as ringing an endorsement, actually, as Red Sox chairman Tom Werner gave Valentine in an interview with The Boston Globe several days ago.
“I don’t really want to get into that,” Werner told the Globe. “I don’t want to talk too much about him. But he’s had a challenging year. I think, as we’ve said before, he’s doing a good job.”
The lukewarm-at-best comment stood in stark contrast to what Werner said when asked about general manager Ben Cherington.
“He was extremely impressive in his press conference (to announce last week’s blockbuster trade),” said Werner. “But it’s not just that he’s articulate. Ben is methodical. He’s thoughtful. He’s a good manager. He’s a good leader. We give him high marks in how he’s dealt with the challenges this season, and he’s going to be with us for a long time.”
The same can’t be said for Valentine.
Yes, Valentine has a contract for next season, and, yes, by putting Valentine out of his misery, the Red Sox would in effect be eating the money on that contract.
Fortunately, they just cleared $260 million in future payroll. They can probably afford to do what they need to do with Valentine.