The one who got away? Jesús Aguilar, the Indians and capitalizing on an opportunity
Zack Meisel Jun 26, 2018 8
Francisco Lindor, Roberto Pérez and Dan Otero chatted in the corner of the Indians’ clubhouse one recent morning. They marveled at the blossoming of a big guy with a big swing, one with which they’re plenty familiar. They wondered whether the old friend might have a convincing case for an All-Star Game nod.
Jesús Aguilar spent the first nine years of his professional career with the Indians. And that amounted to a grand total of 64 plate appearances with the big-league club, despite some gaudy numbers at various affiliates along the way.
He exhausted his minor-league options and the Brewers selected him off waivers Feb. 2, 2017, about a month after the Indians signed Edwin Encarnacion. That sealed Aguilar’s fate, though it was all but decided long before then.
“We always thought with Aggy that probably the only chance he was going to get here was if somebody got injured, and that didn’t necessarily happen,” Terry Francona said. “He got maybe a few starts here and there. That’s one of the reasons we never tell a guy he can’t play. We just tell them that, at the moment, there’s not a place for you to play here, because he needed an opportunity and he got it and he took advantage of it and he’s really doing well. I don’t think anybody would ever begrudge — we don’t feel like somebody goes somewhere else and you want them to fail.”
Well, Aguilar owns a .955 OPS this season for the Brewers, who essentially cashed in on a scratch-off ticket. That happens. There are so many moving parts, so many bodies in any organization, that players occasionally slip through the cracks or, for whatever reason, bloom elsewhere. There’s a reason the Rule 5 draft exists, after all.
Before Brandon Phillips became a three-time All-Star, the Indians dealt him to the Reds for a nickel and a piece of lint on the dollar. (Of course, the dissension between Phillips and Eric Wedge paved the way for that trade.) Think the Indians wish they still had Chris Archer or Kirby Yates?
Of course, they’ve benefitted from this sort of value chasm or roster crunch on plenty of occasions. They acquired Nick Goody for something called a Yoiber Marquina, simply because the Yankees needed to clear a spot for Aroldis Chapman. Goody excelled in the Indians’ bullpen last year. They claimed Otero, Tyler Olson, Oliver Pérez and Neil Ramírez off waivers over the last few seasons. And we know all about the trades that landed them Corey Kluber, Mike Clevinger and Yan Gomes, to name a few.
It’s easy to say, “Imagine if Aguilar were wearing an Indians uniform while pummeling opposing pitchers.” But sometimes guys also need a change of scenery, a fresh voice to deliver instructions, a new environment and ballpark, new teammates.
“I don’t think the grass is always greener on the other side,” Otero told The Athletic. “A lot of players have to be careful of what they wish for sometimes. Sometimes where you’re at is the best spot for you to be in, but sometimes a change of scenery is what you need. You see it quite a bit in baseball, when guys struggle with a certain team and then go to a new organization, get off to a hot start and that confidence leads to great things. You look at J.D. Martinez in Houston. They let him go, he ends up in Detroit, worked his way through Toledo, got to Detroit and now he’s one of the best right-handed hitters in the game. The ability is there. With Aguilar, he’s taken off over there, for whatever reason, whether it’s comfort level, confidence. The power level has always been there. Sometimes it does absolutely help.”
Sometimes players aren’t positioned to break out until a team has no choice but to offer an opportunity.
“He knew once he was on the team, he couldn’t be optioned down,” Otero said. “He’s out of options. That’s a huge obstacle for some guys to mentally overcome, always looking over their shoulder. He’s out of options, we DFA him, he gets picked up. He knows going into camp, it’s his spot to win, essentially. Once he makes the team, it’s like, ‘I can’t get optioned down.’ I’ve heard guys say that. That makes a big difference. You’re not looking over your shoulder. Every day, every at-bat, you’re not thinking, ‘If I get out, I get sent down.’ So that helps.”
And, sometimes, it’s a numbers game. Carlos Santana was always blocking one of the two avenues Aguilar could travel to the majors. Nick Swisher, Mike Napoli, Brandon Moss and Encarnacion occupied the other.
That’s not to say Aguilar didn’t deserve a longer look. He never received more than 38 plate appearances in a season with the Indians. And in 2015, once the Indians dumped Swisher, Moss and David Murphy in summer trades, they could have granted the guy a trial at first base or designated hitter. Instead, he appeared in seven games.
“We had a little bit of a split camp,” Francona said.
Following the trade of Swisher — the final nail in the coffin of the Indians’ veterans — Santana started each of the team’s 55 games. The other first base/DH slot went to the following players:
20: Chris Johnson
9: Jason Kipnis
9: Ryan Raburn
7: Michael Brantley
4: Jerry Sands
2: Yan Gomes
1: Roberto Pérez
1: No DH because of interleague play
As for Aguilar? Two starts, both in the final week of the season.
Imagine how many starts Johnson, a veteran playing out the final years of his inflated contract, would have secured had he not suffered a spider bite on his hand, causing him to miss nearly three weeks.
Maybe the Indians would have signed Mike Napoli the ensuing offseason anyway. But you don’t know what you don’t know, and it’s tough to award Aguilar a big-league job after he received only 20 plate appearances in 2015.
Aguilar spent three seasons at Class AAA Columbus.
2014: .304/.395/.511 slash line, 12.8% BB rate, 19.2% K rate, 149 wRC+
2015: .267/.332/.439 slash line, 8.2% BB rate, 20.2% K rate, 121 wRC+
2016: .247/.319/.472 slash line, 9.2% BB rate, 19.0% K rate, 125 wRC+
His production in limited trials with the Indians during those three seasons:
64 PAs: .172/.234/.190 slash line, 6.3% BB rate, 32.8% K rate, 19 OPS+
And the last two seasons with the Brewers …
2017: .265/.331/.505 slash line, 8.0% BB rate, 30.2% K rate, 112 wRC+
2018: .299/.358/.597 slash line, 8.7% BB rate, 24.9% K rate, 150 wRC+
His hard contact rate stands at 45.3 percent (the league average is 35.5 percent). And even with Eric Thames and Ryan Braun in the fold, he has earned daily playing time since the calendar flipped to May.
“I knew wherever he went, he was going to hit,” Lindor told The Athletic. “That’s what he did every year in the minor leagues. He hit. Low A, High A, Double A, Triple A. He did it every single year. He did it in Triple A a couple of times. It’s just a matter of getting the opportunity. Whether it was here or somewhere else, I knew he was going to get it done.”
Eventually, the options game can catch up with a team. The Indians had to cut Gio Urshela loose earlier this season. They may soon have to make a similar decision on Ryan Merritt.
In an alternate universe, the Indians would’ve given Aguilar a longer look, and in that trial, he would’ve revealed to the club that he could, in fact, hold down first base. He’d still be earning the major-league minimum, too. But who knows how things would have unfolded without Napoli or Encarnacion?
That’s why the Indians don’t look at Aguilar, or anyone in this sort of situation, as “the one who got away.” He’s just the one who never got much of a chance in Cleveland, and now looks the part in Milwaukee.
“He can go the other way. He can go up the middle,” Otero said. “Watching him and preparing to face him this year, you couldn’t just throw a fastball away. He could hit it out to right field. You have to be really fine and attack him carefully. There’s a reason why he’s in the 3-hole over there. It’s ’cause he’s freaking good right now. It’s not by accident.”
"I've suffered a great many tragedies in my life....most of them never happened". Mark Twain