Cleveland Indians: Can they fix the bullpen? -- Terry Pluto
Updated May 19, 8:51 PM; Posted May 19, 8:01 AM
By Terry Pluto, The Plain
Dealerterrypluto2003@yahoo.com
THE STARTING ROTATION
1. The starting pitching is borderline great. The rotation's ERA is 3.42, second best in the American League. It's even better than a year ago, when Tribe starters led the A.L. with a 3.52 ERA.
2. The rotation is even more impressive considering Josh Tomlin has been the No. 5 starter with an 0-4 record and 7.84 ERA. Otherwise, it's Corey Kluber (7-2, 2.36 ERA), Trevor Bauer (3-3, 2.59 ERA), Mike Clevinger (3-1, 2.87 ERA) and Carlos Carrasco (5-2, 3.66 ERA).
3. The average American League starter has a 4.36 ERA. The Tribe's rotation minus Tomlin is at 2.85.
4. No matter what the Indians and Kluber say, the Cy Young Award winner was bothered by a bad back in the playoffs against the Yankees. He has pitched the second-most innings (876) in baseball between 2014-17. Only Max Scherzer (878) has more.
So it's good news that Kluber remains strong and healthy at the age of 32.
5. This is Clevinger's first full season in the rotation. He has been excellent. Bauer is better than ever. Carrasco generally has been superb. The Indians have Adam Plutko ready in the minors if they want to replace Tomlin - and that's a move I'd have made a few weeks ago.
6. I'm dwelling on the starters because it's the rotation that gives the Tribe a chance to pull out of the early season funk - and to be a factor in the playoffs. The bullpen has been a mess, but it's easier to fix a bullpen than the rotation.
THE BULLPEN
1. This is where everything has gone wrong ... absolutely, positively EVERYTHING. Not a single reliever is pitching as well as he did in 2017. The problems are so much deeper than simply losing Bryan Shaw to Colorado via free agency.
2. A year ago, the Tribe's bullpen had a 2.89 ERA - best in the American League. This season, it's 5.68 - the AL's worst. Yes, the bullpen is as bad as it seems - if not worse.
3. It's fair to criticize the front office for not replacing Joe Smith or Shaw with at least one veteran reliever. Smith has had a miserable start in Houston with a 7.30 ERA after signing a 2-year, $15 million deal. Shaw is 1-1 with a 4.71 ERA in Colorado. His ERA is 9.35 in Denver, 1.46 away from the Mile High City, where thin air often makes life miserable for pitchers.
4. From 2015-17, Zach McAllister had a 9-8 record and 2.99 ERA. In 183 innings, he struck out 204 batters. The Indians thought the right-hander was a good candidate to move into Shaw's seventh-inning role. At the very least, they expected far more than McAllister's 7.47 ERA.
5. Dan Otero is also a member of McAllister's 7.47 club. That's right, they share the same sky-high ERA. From 2015-17, Otero had a 3.35 ERA. The point is Otero and McAllister had been effective for a few years, but both have collapsed this season.
6. A question facing the Tribe is, do they wait for McAllister and/or Otero to pull out of it? Or are they like some relievers who suddenly lose their edge? In 2015-16, Jeff Manship was effective. In 2017, he went to Korea for money. He's now out of pro baseball.
7. Nick Goody had a 2.80 ERA last season. He is out for a while with an elbow injury. His ERA is 6.94.
8. Andrew Miller's hamstring injury kept him out for 16 days. It was costly to have an All-Star reliever unavailable. Miller missed 37 games and was on the disabled list twice with knee problems a year ago. Can he stay healthy?
9. Cody Allen (2-1, 3.18 ERA) has converted 6-of-7 saves. But he's also had some rough outings. At times, he's putting in more innings than the Tribe would like because of all the bullpen issues.
10. Tyler Olson has a 6.23 ERA. But the Indians realize they have been using Olson too much vs. right-handed hitters. The left-handed reliever has held lefties to 3-for-26 (.115). But righties are 9-for-25 (.360).
10. Because the starters have often been so dominating, the bullpen has pitched the fewest innings in the American League. Just imagine how awful it would be if the Indians had an average rotation and the bullpen was needed even more?
11. Since Terry Francona became manager, the Indians have had an elite bullpen. In his first five years, they ranked first once, second twice, fourth and eighth. That's also why this has been such a shock not only to fans, but to the manager.
12. Is losing pitching coach Mickey Callaway (now Mets manager) the reason? Hard to know. The starting rotation is thriving under Carl Willis. The Indians changed bullpen coaches from Jason Bere to Scott Atchison. Blaming the coach often seems too easy an answer.
13. The front office is talking to other teams about trades, but few teams make trades in May. That usually doesn't happen until July, as the deadline approaches.
14. Meanwhile, they are sorting through recent bargain pick-ups. Ben Taylor (claimed on waivers from Boston) is intriguing. Neil Ramirez, Oliver Drake and Evan Marshall are guys added from other teams.
15. In the past, the Indians have found short-term help for the bullpen this way. Goody (Yankees), McAllister (Yankees), Otero (A's) and Olson (Royals) all came to the Tribe in minor deals.
16. What the Indians don't have is anyone in the minors ready right now to help. Cameron Hill had an impressive training camp. Francona was talking about the 23-year-old right-hander being a bullpen possibility this season. But Hill injured his forearm right before the Class AAA season opened. He came back a few days ago. Hill is 16-11 with a 2.24 ERA in the minors.
17. For now, the Indians are looking for help "internally." They are running auditions, hoping someone can help in the middle innings. They also need Miller to stay healthy.
ABOUT THE INDIANS
1. Melky Cabrera was 1-for-17 when he first reported to Class AAA. Since then, the veteran outfielder is 10-for-26 and getting into game shape. He could be with the Indians in 7-10 days. The Tribe ideally would like to give him another week in Columbus. The 33-year-old Cabrera wasn't signed until early May.
2. Yandy Diaz came into the season as a .321 career hitter in Class AAA. But he is hitting only .250 (.705 OPS) at Columbus. He had some minor injuries. He is 24-for-96 with only five extra base hits, 10 RBI.
3. Top prospect Triston McKenzie developed a forearm problem late in spring training. He has been pitching in extended spring in Goodyear. In about two weeks, he is expected to report to a team - possibly Class AA Akron. McKenzie was the Class A Carolina League pitcher of the year with a 12-6 record and 3.46 ERA at age 19 last season.
4. The Indians continue to work with Brady Aiken on arm strength. He also is in Goodyear. The 2015 first-rounder may report to a team in 6-8 weeks.
5. Erik Gonzalez is off to an excellent start as utility player, hitting .382 (13-of-34) heading into the weekend. I was pleased to see the Tribe play him at first base a few times against left-handed pitchers. Yonder Alonso is a .178 hitter vs. lefties in the last two seasons.
6. Tyler Naquin is probably out for about three weeks with his hamstring injury. He was hitting .333 when injured last weekend.
7. Why is Brandon Guyer playing against right-handed pitching? He is 1-for-30 with 12 strikeouts this season. For his career, he is a .222 hitter (.612 OPS) vs. righties compared to .278 (.829 OPS) vs. lefties.
8. Danny Salazar is starting to throw off the mound in Goodyear, but no timetable is set for his return. A healthy Salazar could help the bullpen, but who knows when he'll be healthy.