Re: Just Baseball: Major League teams OTHER THAN the Tribe
Posted: Mon Nov 17, 2014 6:54 pm
Someone else agrees with me.
Martin signing necessary, corrects past mistake
In acquiring top-notch backstop, Blue Jays paying for letting Gomes go
By Anthony Castrovince / MLB.com | @castrovince | 4:15 PM ET
For a born-and-bred Canuck, for easily the top catcher in the free-agent class (if not the only viable everyday option in the free-agent class), for a guy whose pitch-framing, game-calling prowess, offensive impact and conditioning diligence make him a better bet than most to age gracefully behind the plate, for an organization that needs to have a win-now mentality, the reported five-year, $82 million commitment the Blue Jays are making to Russell Martin makes sense.
If only it weren't necessary in the first place.
Two years ago, the Blue Jays traded both Yan Gomes and Mike Aviles to the Indians for a hard-throwing reliever named Esmil Rogers. It seemed relatively harmless at the time. Lest I come across as some sort of hindsight-aided snob, let me finesse the point: Nobody thought Toronto was getting totally hosed on that trade, Cleveland included. Aviles and Gomes were both best described as utilitymen, and Rogers' raw stuff made him an encouraging relief option. Maybe the sheer 2-for-1 nature of the deal and Aviles' established identity as a usable and pliable infield piece gave a perceived edge to the Indians, but certainly nobody thought Gomes was on the verge of becoming one of the best catchers in the American League (again, the Tribe included).
Well, two years later, we know that was a terrible trade for Toronto, and now we have an $82 million price tag to put a figure on just how costly it was in the long run.
Major Hot Stove movesMajor Hot Stove moves 8:19
MLB Network's Hot Stove discusses Russell Martin signing with Toronto and the trade sending Jason Heyward to the Cardinals
Gomes was a harder worker, better listener, more adaptive hitter and simply stronger defensive asset than advertised, and Cleveland has him signed at ridiculously team-friendly terms through at least 2019 (with team options for '20 and '21). Thanks to Gomes, the Indians have had the highest wins-above-average marks (per Baseball Reference) at catcher in the AL each of the last two seasons.
The Blue Jays, meanwhile, had the lowest such mark in 2013 and the fourth lowest in '14. Their need for an upgrade was clear, and any area of upgrade potential on this Toronto team must be addressed in the immediate, because the Blue Jays' window to win with a ballclub built around Jose Bautista, Edwin Encarnacion and the like is in the here and now.
So while you've got to hate the fact that this need presented itself, given the way Rogers quickly flamed out and Gomes (and Aviles) flourished elsewhere, you've got to give the Blue Jays credit for filling it so quickly and decisively.
Martin is a natural fit. He was born in Toronto, and he's proud of his roots and ready to take whatever pitching staff he inherits to another level. Martin did it with the Pirates, and he can do it north of the border, too.
It's no coincidence that the Pirates' only postseason appearances in the last 22 years coincided with Martin's two seasons in black and gold. Ask scouts or even some people in that clubhouse, and they'll tell you there's an argument to be made that Martin was every bit as valuable to those '13 and '14 Bucs teams as Andrew McCutchen, the '13 National League Most Valuable Player Award winner. The Pirates don't win in '13 and '14 without successful reclamation projects for the likes of Francisco Liriano and Edinson Volquez and sterling defensive play; Martin's intellect and input was a big part of both of those traits.
For the small-market Pirates, keeping Martin never seemed particularly realistic. That's why the club acted swiftly to swap for Francisco Cervelli from the Yankees last week. And it is true that, from Pittsburgh's perspective, the notion of committing, say, more than 20 percent the player payroll (which is what this Martin contract would have meant for a team with a $72 million payroll in 2014) to an aging catcher didn't make a lick of sense.
For the Blue Jays, that percentage is considerably less drastic (Toronto had a $137 million payroll in 2014), and this contract is the first sign that after the unmistakable quiet of last winter and the '14 Trade Deadline, this is a team ready to do what must be done to bridge the gap between here and October.
Besides, I'd be slightly less concerned about the catcher aging curve with Martin than I would be with most. Beyond the obvious points of appeal -- the .764 OPS over the last two seasons, the career caught-stealing rate of 32 percent -- one of Martin's signature skills is his pitch framing. It's a skill that has been increasingly appreciated in today's game, and it's one that shouldn't be affected by age.
Defensive Player: Martin, CDefensive Player: Martin, C 1:37
The Pirates' Russell Martin wins the Defensive Player of the Year Award at catcher
Then there's the matter of Martin's offseason and in-season work ethic. MMA training, Pilates, Muscle Activation Techniques -- you name the rigourous routine, Martin has tried it. He has been both the poster boy for the "best shape of my life" adage that we all snicker at each spring, and he's also the proof that, yes, sometimes guys really are reporting to camp in great shape, and it has an impact in how they hold up to the grind.
So on the whole, this is a fine signing for the Blue Jays. The free-agent market beyond Martin was abysmal, and the trade market doesn't figure to be much better. An overpay is easier to stomach when you know it's the absolute best move you could make to improve an area of your team that needed improving.
As far as the Gomes trade, well, that still stings. Every team in MLB makes multiple evaluative errors every year, and some are more costly than others. (Indeed, the Yankees are probably still kicking themselves for not re-signing Martin at a reasonable rate before 2013, because that eventually led to the gargantuan $85 million commitment to Brian McCann.)
The Blue Jays are going to pay a lot of money to correct the Gomes mistake.
But that's a heck of a lot better than not correcting it at all.
Anthony Castrovince is a reporter for MLB.com. Read his columns and follow him on Twitter at @Castrovince. This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.
Martin signing necessary, corrects past mistake
In acquiring top-notch backstop, Blue Jays paying for letting Gomes go
By Anthony Castrovince / MLB.com | @castrovince | 4:15 PM ET
For a born-and-bred Canuck, for easily the top catcher in the free-agent class (if not the only viable everyday option in the free-agent class), for a guy whose pitch-framing, game-calling prowess, offensive impact and conditioning diligence make him a better bet than most to age gracefully behind the plate, for an organization that needs to have a win-now mentality, the reported five-year, $82 million commitment the Blue Jays are making to Russell Martin makes sense.
If only it weren't necessary in the first place.
Two years ago, the Blue Jays traded both Yan Gomes and Mike Aviles to the Indians for a hard-throwing reliever named Esmil Rogers. It seemed relatively harmless at the time. Lest I come across as some sort of hindsight-aided snob, let me finesse the point: Nobody thought Toronto was getting totally hosed on that trade, Cleveland included. Aviles and Gomes were both best described as utilitymen, and Rogers' raw stuff made him an encouraging relief option. Maybe the sheer 2-for-1 nature of the deal and Aviles' established identity as a usable and pliable infield piece gave a perceived edge to the Indians, but certainly nobody thought Gomes was on the verge of becoming one of the best catchers in the American League (again, the Tribe included).
Well, two years later, we know that was a terrible trade for Toronto, and now we have an $82 million price tag to put a figure on just how costly it was in the long run.
Major Hot Stove movesMajor Hot Stove moves 8:19
MLB Network's Hot Stove discusses Russell Martin signing with Toronto and the trade sending Jason Heyward to the Cardinals
Gomes was a harder worker, better listener, more adaptive hitter and simply stronger defensive asset than advertised, and Cleveland has him signed at ridiculously team-friendly terms through at least 2019 (with team options for '20 and '21). Thanks to Gomes, the Indians have had the highest wins-above-average marks (per Baseball Reference) at catcher in the AL each of the last two seasons.
The Blue Jays, meanwhile, had the lowest such mark in 2013 and the fourth lowest in '14. Their need for an upgrade was clear, and any area of upgrade potential on this Toronto team must be addressed in the immediate, because the Blue Jays' window to win with a ballclub built around Jose Bautista, Edwin Encarnacion and the like is in the here and now.
So while you've got to hate the fact that this need presented itself, given the way Rogers quickly flamed out and Gomes (and Aviles) flourished elsewhere, you've got to give the Blue Jays credit for filling it so quickly and decisively.
Martin is a natural fit. He was born in Toronto, and he's proud of his roots and ready to take whatever pitching staff he inherits to another level. Martin did it with the Pirates, and he can do it north of the border, too.
It's no coincidence that the Pirates' only postseason appearances in the last 22 years coincided with Martin's two seasons in black and gold. Ask scouts or even some people in that clubhouse, and they'll tell you there's an argument to be made that Martin was every bit as valuable to those '13 and '14 Bucs teams as Andrew McCutchen, the '13 National League Most Valuable Player Award winner. The Pirates don't win in '13 and '14 without successful reclamation projects for the likes of Francisco Liriano and Edinson Volquez and sterling defensive play; Martin's intellect and input was a big part of both of those traits.
For the small-market Pirates, keeping Martin never seemed particularly realistic. That's why the club acted swiftly to swap for Francisco Cervelli from the Yankees last week. And it is true that, from Pittsburgh's perspective, the notion of committing, say, more than 20 percent the player payroll (which is what this Martin contract would have meant for a team with a $72 million payroll in 2014) to an aging catcher didn't make a lick of sense.
For the Blue Jays, that percentage is considerably less drastic (Toronto had a $137 million payroll in 2014), and this contract is the first sign that after the unmistakable quiet of last winter and the '14 Trade Deadline, this is a team ready to do what must be done to bridge the gap between here and October.
Besides, I'd be slightly less concerned about the catcher aging curve with Martin than I would be with most. Beyond the obvious points of appeal -- the .764 OPS over the last two seasons, the career caught-stealing rate of 32 percent -- one of Martin's signature skills is his pitch framing. It's a skill that has been increasingly appreciated in today's game, and it's one that shouldn't be affected by age.
Defensive Player: Martin, CDefensive Player: Martin, C 1:37
The Pirates' Russell Martin wins the Defensive Player of the Year Award at catcher
Then there's the matter of Martin's offseason and in-season work ethic. MMA training, Pilates, Muscle Activation Techniques -- you name the rigourous routine, Martin has tried it. He has been both the poster boy for the "best shape of my life" adage that we all snicker at each spring, and he's also the proof that, yes, sometimes guys really are reporting to camp in great shape, and it has an impact in how they hold up to the grind.
So on the whole, this is a fine signing for the Blue Jays. The free-agent market beyond Martin was abysmal, and the trade market doesn't figure to be much better. An overpay is easier to stomach when you know it's the absolute best move you could make to improve an area of your team that needed improving.
As far as the Gomes trade, well, that still stings. Every team in MLB makes multiple evaluative errors every year, and some are more costly than others. (Indeed, the Yankees are probably still kicking themselves for not re-signing Martin at a reasonable rate before 2013, because that eventually led to the gargantuan $85 million commitment to Brian McCann.)
The Blue Jays are going to pay a lot of money to correct the Gomes mistake.
But that's a heck of a lot better than not correcting it at all.
Anthony Castrovince is a reporter for MLB.com. Read his columns and follow him on Twitter at @Castrovince. This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.