Livid fan says Guardians aren’t building on last season’s success: Hey, Hoynsie!
Updated: Feb. 08, 2025, 10:36 a.m.|Published: Feb. 08, 2025, 5:05 a.m.
Livid fan says Guardians aren’t building on last season’s success: Hey, Hoynsie!
Updated: Feb. 08, 2025, 10:36 a.m.|Published: Feb. 08, 2025, 5:05 a.m.
By Paul Hoynes, cleveland.com
CLEVELAND, Ohio — Do you have a Guardians question that you’d like to have answered in Hey, Hoynsie? You can subscribe to Subtext here, text Hoynsie at 216-208-4346 for a two-week free trial or email him at
phoynes@cleveland.com.
Hey, Hoynsie: The Guardians go to the American League Championship Series and they’ve spent the offseason acting like they’re rebuilding. Second base is wide open. They’re counting heavily on unproven Kyle Manzardo at first base/DH. Right field continues to be a joke and the rotation has three question marks. Instead of building on the ALCS appearance, they’ve regressed. This fan is livid. — Tom Koch.
Hey, Tom: It’s true the Guards have had a disjointed offseason. They’ve added and subtracted from the roster. I think Manzardo is going to be fine. I agree they need more production from right field. There are some interesting starting pitchers still available on the free agent market and there has to be concern how they replace Josh Naylor’s 31 homers and 108 RBI.
The Guardians, however, have made it clear over the last few years that they’re going to rely heavily on their homegrown roster. The result has been two AL Central titles in the last three years.
Hey, Hoynsie: I was shocked when I read that Juan Brito, who has a chance to win the Guardians’ second base job, has only one minor league option left. Maybe it’s because he has been on the 40-man roster. — Glenn Berger, Strongsville.
Hey, Glenn:
When the Guardians acquired Brito from Colorado for Nolan Jones on Nov. 11, 2022, they put him on the 40-man roster. When he didn’t break camp with the Guardians out of spring training in 2023 and 2024, that accounted for two of his three minor league options. So he’s got one left.
Hey, Hoynsie: Do you think if Indians Gold Glove center fielder Kenny Lofton had played in a big market that he’d already be in the Hall of Fame? In general it seems voting is skewed against the guys who played most of their careers in small markets. — Jim B., Independence.
Hey, Jim: No, I don’t. Through most of Lofton’s career in Cleveland, the Indians were one of the best teams in baseball. They were in the postseason almost every year, which gives a player a lot of visibility. Lofton went on to play for the Yankees, Giants, Dodgers, Phillies and Rangers, all big-market teams.
He appeared in 20 postseason series, playing in 95 games.
I think the thing that hurt Lofton was that he only appeared for one year on the BBWAA Hall of Fame ballot in 2013. He definitely deserved a longer look, and I hope he gets it through the Contemporary Era Ballot, which is the reformed Veterans Committee. That ballot will be announced during the 2025 season for induction in 2026.
Hey Hoynsie: Is the MLB TV deal the long-term plan for the Guardians? Or is this just a short-term thing before going back to a different network? — Matt, Seattle.
Hey, Matt I have not been able to nail that down, but this is what I do know: All of the teams that have had MLB produce and distribute their games have returned the following year.
I’m sure MLB has a long-term plan to bring as many of its teams under one broadcasting umbrella as it can. So if the Guardians decided to stay with them this offseason, after the Brewers and Reds left for more money at FanDuel Sports Network, formerly Bally Sports, it seems the Guards would be open for more than a one-year stay.
Hey, Hoynsie: I really believe that MLB would be a lot better if there were no more “major markets” vs. everyone else in terms of salary, trades or player movement. The only way that is going to happen is a salary cap like the NFL’s. If that takes a year-long strike, bring it on. — Tom Jones, Rochester, New York.
Hey, Tom: Easy for you to say. The players more than once have shown that they’re willing to strike to prevent a salary cap. In these situations over the years, it’s usually the owners that blink first.
Hey, Hoynsie: Are the Guardians trying to control the market on comeback pitchers? The trainers will be busy this year. — Roger Amoroso, Macedonia.
Hey, Roger: I think you’re referring to Shane Bieber and Vincent Velasquez, who are recovering from right elbow surgeries. Bieber re-signed with the Guardians, but it’s unclear when he’ll be able to take the mound. Velasquez just agreed to a minor league deal after not pitching last season following elbow surgery. The Guards, however, have not announced the signing because he must pass his physical next week when spring training opens on Tuesday in Goodyear, Arizona.
If Bieber or Velasquez can contribute like Matthew Boyd did last year, that would be a good thing. Boyd, of course, bounced back from Tommy John surgery late last season. Alex Cobb, the other pitching gamble last year, did not work out so well.
Hey, Hoynsie: Who was the last Guardians starter to pitch a complete game? Do you think that complete games in general are becoming a vanishing part of the game? — Karen K., Westlake.
Hey, Karen: Shane Bieber was the last Cleveland pitcher to throw a complete game. Bieber threw an eight-inning complete game against the Mets on May 21, 2023, in the second game of a doubleheader at Citi Field. Bieber in a 2-1 loss allowed two earned runs on seven hits. New York’s Justin Verlander went eight innings for the win. He was removed after the Mets broke a 1-1 tie with a run in the eighth inning.
Yes, the complete game is vanishing as more and more starters are removed after five innings and replaced by an endless stream of relievers. Last year there were 26 complete games thrown in the big leagues. In 1975, Catfish Hunter of the Yankees threw 30 all by himself. Indians Hall of Famer Bob Feller threw 279 complete games in his career.
<