Guardians
Stephen Vogt says rotation, bullpen, and bench battles remain unresolved as Opening Day approaches: Guardians takeaways
Updated: Mar. 19, 2026, 7:28 p.m.|Published: Mar. 19, 2026, 7:23 p.m.
By Joe Noga, cleveland.com
CLEVELAND, Ohio — With one week remaining before Opening Day, Guardians manager Stephen Vogt and his staff are working through what he calls “some really difficult decisions” as they finalize the team’s 26-man roster.
The decision-making process has become more complex due to a competitive spring training camp that has produced multiple viable candidates for the final roster spots across the rotation, bullpen, and bench.
“There’s still some decisions to be made,” Vogt said. “It’s been a really competitive camp. We were hoping that we would have this problem.”
Vogt said just because the club encouraged competition in camp does not mean the prospect of having to cut players is something they are looking forward to.
“We don’t like it,” he said. “It’s not fun to have these conversations. But at the same time we’re getting down to it and we know we’ve got some decisions to make here in the next few days.”
The Guardians are taking a collaborative approach to constructing their Opening Day roster, with input from both the major league coaching staff and the front office playing crucial roles in the final determinations.
“It’s a very collaborative discussion here,” Vogt explained. “There’s a lot of people that have input and we want to hear everybody’s input we put a lot of stock into the Opening Day roster, as well we should. It’s an honor.”
However, Vogt was quick to emphasize that the Opening Day roster represents just the beginning of what will likely be a fluid season-long process of roster management.
“We’ve used over 50 players the last two years and we know that the team we leave here with won’t necessarily be the team we have at the end of the year or a week from now or a month from now,” he said.
Beyond on-field performance, the decision-making process must also account for various contractual considerations that could impact both individual players and the organization’s long-term depth. Veterans such as Rhys Hoskins have opt-out clauses in their contract that necessitate decisions being made within a certain timeframe.
“There’s other ramifications,” Vogt said. “There’s a lot of things that we’re working through and trying to put together the best 26 that we can to Goodyear.”
George Valera, Hunter Gaddis ‘progressing’
Complicating the roster picture are injury situations involving outfielder George Valera (calf) and reliever Hunter Gaddis (right forearm). Neither player has been able to return to game action in the last two weeks. While Vogt confirmed that both players are “progressing well” and improving day by day, the compressed timeline is creating urgency around their status.
“We’re running out of time,” Vogt said. “We realize that, and so we may have to make some decisions soon.”
Trevor Stephan, Juan Brito sent to Triple-A
Among the roster moves already made, the Guardians reassigned Trevor Stephan to Triple-A Columbus, along with optioning infielder Juan Brito.
Stephan appeared in four Cactus League games and logged 3 1/3 innings with a 2.70 ERA and five strikeouts. He allowed one earned run allowed and four walks, but continues to struggle with fastball velocity after 2024 elbow surgery.
The Guardians are paying Stephan $3.5 million the final year of a four-year, $10 million deal he signed in March of 2023.
“With Steph we’re seeing the pitch ability is there, the execution is there, the movement on his offspeed is there, it’s just not coming out the way he would like it to or we would like it to,” Vogt said. “We’re all rooting for Steph to get back on the right track.”
Brito hit .145 in 14 games with a home run, six RBI and 11 strikeouts. Vogt expressed confidence in what he saw from the switch-hitting infielder
“We saw at times really good at-bat quality,” Vogt said. “We saw a really good body of work from Juan this spring.”
As part of Brito’s development plan in the minors, the organization will focus on building his defensive versatility across multiple infield positions and potentially right field.
“The more spots we can get his bat in the order the better,” Vogt explained, adding that Brito remains “one phone call away” if the team needs him.
With the clock ticking toward Opening Day, the Guardians’ brain trust will continue weighing performance, potential, and practicality as they finalize their roster decisions in the coming days.
<